‘You keep crying over a man and perpetuating that sad black female sufferance... That’s not strength that’s stupidity’
It seems like everyone has an opinion on Beyoncé’s Lemonade. The heavily hyped visual album, which premiered this weekend on HBO, has garnered glowing praise from critics and fans, with many calling it a perfect homage to the black female experience.
Inevitably, though, others have not been so impressed. In a series of tweets posted yesterday afternoon, Azealia Banks shared her thoughts on the record – calling it both anti-feminist, colourist, and harmful to black women. “This heartbroken black female narrative you keep trying to push is the antithesis of what feminism is,” the rapper wrote. “You been singing about this nigga for years and he still playing you. That’s not strength that’s stupidity.”
The 12-track album follows the singer’s emotional journey as she gets to grips with a cheating partner, with many listeners speculating that it could be an autobiographical account of Beyoncé’s marriage to Jay Z. “You keep crying over a man and perpetuating that sad black female sufferance,” added Banks, referencing the star’s ultimate decision to ‘forgive’ her husband. “It’s not what the national black women’s conversation needs right now. More pain more suffering in the face of a man”.
This heartbroken black female narrative you keep trying to push is the Antithesis of what feminism is
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
You been singing about this nigga for years and he still playing you. That's not strength that's stupidity
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
And it's not what the national black women's conversation needs right now. More pain more suffering in the face of a man
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
You keep crying over a man and perpetuating that sad black female sufferance and it's Not good for what we're trying to accomplish here
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
She made a song about big noses and hot sauce then put up a tour charging $1300 to ppl she knows damn sure can't afford that
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 25, 2016
All the lightskinned chicks in the video... The only dark skinned one (serena) was writhing on the floor while litebrite sat on throne. ha
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
Banks, whose latest video for “The Big Big Beat” dropped yesterday, also accused Beyoncé of being a “thief”, asserting that she had been “pumping African traditional religions/witchcraft” for a “long” time. She continued: “She’s not a ‘sister’, she’s a poacher. She’s a thief. Sisters don’t steal, sisters share.”
If that wasn’t enough shaking of the Beyhive in one day, Iggy Azalea also took to Twitter to share her issues. After being called a ‘becky’ on the social media site – in reference Beyoncé’s already infamous “Becky with the good hair” line – the Australian rapper vented her frustrations, calling the slur “stereotypical” and “not cool”.
“Dont ever call me a becky,” Azalea wrote. “Generalizing ANY race by calling them one sterotypical name for said race. i personally dont think is very cool, the end (sic).”
@iggys_bitch dont ever call me a becky.
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
@phagmob@iggys_bitch it was used as a play on brain and brian. you would not be down if i started calling all black men "deshawns"
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
@phagmob@iggys_bitch and by the way, this is not bey shade. i love her and the album. but my name is iggy, and you will all call me that.
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
@phagmob generalizing ANY race by calling them one sterotypical name for said race. i personally dont think is very cool, the end.
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
@phagmob girl BYE. do you know how many time ppl have called me BECKY? it didnt have any kind of positive intention behind it. dont start.
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
@SamMaffiaOnline I dont care. Dont call all asian women "ming lee" dont call white women "becky" dont call black women "sha nay nay"
— IGGY AZALEA (@IGGYAZALEA) April 25, 2016
Banks, once again, shared her opinion on the subject.
It is a racial slur. Reserved for condescending white women. Fuck Becky https://t.co/oRaEIMRYLa
— BRUJA DEL BLOQUE (@AZEALIABANKS) April 26, 2016
As ever, there’s been no word from Beyoncé’s camp on any of the above (and, let’s be honest, there probably never will be). But do you think either of them have a point? Could Becky be seen as a damaging “racial slur”? And could Lemonade actually be promoting harmful stereotypes?