Ryan Murphy has announced another new face joining the cast of the upcoming tenth season of American Horror Story. Step forward model and actress Kaia Gerber, who’s set to star alongside AHS faves Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, and Angelica Ross, as well as fellow newcomer Macauley Culkin. 

Dropping the news via Instagram, Murphy wrote: “Very excited to announce that Kaia Gerber is joining the American Horror Story family.” Having previously starred in The Last Day of Summer and Sister Cities, Gerber has taken a step back from the runway in recent seasons to focus on her acting (although she did make time to pop up in Coach’s recent star-studded campaign). 

The announcement follows soon after the new season’s title, Double Feature, was revealed. Right now, there’s little information about what that’s actually going to look like, bar a cryptic teaser posted on social media revealing “two horrifying stories” will be told in tandem – ”one by the sea… one by the sand.” 

Fans have been speculating that mermaids or sirens could play a part in the plot, after Murphy shared a photo of a pair of hands clambering up a grassy sand bank by the beach last March. “Things are beginning to wash up on shore…” he wrote in the accompanying caption. Stay tuned to find out, we guess.