Pin It
Sunday Riley
courtesy of Instagram/@sundayriley

Cult skincare brand Sunday Riley found guilty of leaving fake reviews

TextAlex Peters

The US Federal Trade Commission found the company founder, senior bosses, and staff were deliberately misleading customers

The cult US-based skincare brand Sunday Riley has been found by the Federal Trade Commission to have posted fake reviews of their products in order to boost sales. 

In a complaint filed on October 21, the watchdog alleges that between November 2015 and August 2017, managers of Sunday Riley, including founder Riley, posted faked positive reviews of products on Sephora’s website and asked its employees to do the same. 

The FTC found the brand guilty of being in violation of the Federal Trade Commission Act on two counts: making false or misleading endorsement claims and deceptive failure to disclose material connections with endorsers – i.e. deceptively failing to disclose that the reviews were written by Riley or her employees.

The watchdog first began investigating Sunday Riley after a former employee exposed the brand last October. Taking to social platform Reddit, the anonymous poster accused Sunday Riley of forcing their employees to write fake reviews for their products, a practice that was allegedly ordered from the top: “We were forced to write fake reviews for our products on an ongoing basis, which came from Sunday Riley herself and her Head of Sales,” they write.

The whistleblower also attached an email allegedly sent to employees from the brand which includes a step-by-step guide to installing a VPN so that the reviews don’t get traced back to their IP addresses, as well as suggestions of what to put in the reviews and how to appear more “relatable”.

After Sunday Riley received criticism following the accusations, the brand responded, confirming the claims.

Following the complaint by the FTC, a settlement with Sunday Riley has been reached which prohibits the brand from posting fake reviews in the future. However, Sunday Riley will not be required to pay a fine, issue refunds to customers or admit to any wrongdoing, Buzzfeed News reports

Some at the FTC, however, feel that the ruling is too lenient. In an official dissent, FTC Commissioners Rohit Chopra and Kelly Slaughter who voted against the settlement said the agreement “will not deter other firms from engaging in fake review fraud, which is a growing problem online”.

“This settlement sends the wrong message to the marketplace,” they write. “Dishonest firms may come to conclude that posting fake reviews is a viable strategy, given the proposed outcome here. Honest firms, who are the biggest victims of this fraud, may be wondering if they are losing out by following the law. Consumers may come to lack confidence that reviews are truthful.”  

Read Next
spirited away Studio Ghibli nails makeup
This new trend takes inspiration from all your fave Studio Ghibli films Beauty news
Raisa Flowers
Watch Raisa Flowers do a cute beachy make-up look perfect for summer Beauty news
Pretty Woman
How to use bathing to combat your quarantine stress and insomnia Beauty Feature
Noto Botanics
Noto Botanics is the political, sustainable brand you’ve been looking for Beauty Feature
Till Janz Magic Youth
Dazed Beauty Club is officially open for business Beauty news
Gigi Hadid
Gigi Hadid: ‘People are so fast to do permanent things to their face’ Beauty news
Manny MUA Gutierrez lunar beauty prism blush launch
Manny MUA: ‘The beauty world tends to be an ugly place’ Beauty Feature
Miley Cyrus
Miley Cyrus’s mum has given her a choppy pixie mullet in isolation Beauty news
loveleo Leo Reilly musician Los Angeles
Step into the off-kilter world of musician and TikTok heartthrob LoveLeo Beauty Feature
Dazed Karen Elson
Shon Hyungsun Ju brings the drama with his hair-raising wigs Spotlight
Skincare brand Typology is on a mission to demystify the industry Beauty news
Blok London Letty Mitchell
How to maintain your physical and mental wellbeing after lockdown Beauty Feature
Jeffree Star
Jeffree Star isn't going to apologise for the ‘Cremated’ palette backlash Beauty news
Mona Kattan
Mona Kattan on how to change your life with fragrance Beauty Feature
Erika Lust masturbation month sex toy guide
Erika Lust on her favourite sex toys and how to use them Guide
Jeffree Star palette controversy cremated
Jeffree Star causes more controversy with his ‘Cremated’ palette drop Beauty news